The Rosedale Banishment
East Taylor Township, Cambria County, Pennsylvania
Marker Inscription
On September 7, 1923, in response to rising racial tensions, Johnstown Mayor Joseph Cauffiel ordered all Blacks and Mexicans who had lived in the area for less than seven years to leave. By some reports, more than 2,000 people were forced out under threat of imprisonment. News reports, some by Black journalists and activists, prompted a state investigation and turned public opinion against Cauffiel, who lost reelection.
Erected by Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission
The Story
On September 7, 1923, amid rising racial hostility, Johnstown Mayor Joseph Cauffiel ordered every Black and Mexican resident who had lived in the area less than seven years to leave. By some accounts more than 2,000 people were driven out under threat of jail. The episode drew national attention—much of it from Black journalists and activists—prompting a state investigation and a public backlash that helped cost Cauffiel his reelection.
Why it matters
The Rosedale Banishment stands as a stark record of Northern racial expulsion in the 1920s and of how Black-led journalism could turn injustice into public reckoning.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
The early 1920s in industrial Pennsylvania were a time of boom and backlash. Towns like Johnstown, built on steel and coal, had drawn waves of newcomers—including Black families moving north in the Great Migration and Mexican laborers seeking work. That growth collided with a decade of intense nativism and racial hostility across the United States.
This was the era when the Ku Klux Klan surged well beyond the South, targeting not only Black Americans but immigrants and Catholics, and when "Americanism" was too often defined by exclusion. The North was not the refuge it was imagined to be; discrimination and violence followed migrants across state lines.
Against that backdrop, Cambria County in 1923 became the setting for one of the starkest official acts of racial expulsion in the North. The marker places the story in the "Progressive & Modern Era," a reminder that even amid reform and modernization, the machinery of local government could be turned against a community's most vulnerable residents.
People & events
On September 7, 1923, Johnstown Mayor Joseph Cauffiel issued an extraordinary order: every Black and Mexican resident who had lived in the area less than seven years was to leave. By some reports, more than 2,000 people were forced out under threat of imprisonment—families uprooted not for anything they had done, but for who they were and how recently they had arrived.
What makes the Rosedale Banishment resonate is not only the injustice but the response to it. News reports—some written by Black journalists and activists—carried the story beyond Cambria County and refused to let it pass in silence. Their reporting turned a local abuse of power into a matter of public conscience.
The pressure worked. The episode prompted a state investigation and turned public opinion against the mayor, who went on to lose reelection. It is a hard story with a measure of accountability in it: officialdom overreached, the press exposed it, and voters delivered a verdict.
Its place in the American story
The Rosedale Banishment stands as a stark record that racial expulsion was not a Southern phenomenon alone. Northern towns, too, could use the authority of local government to drive out Black and immigrant residents—a truth that complicates any tidy geography of American prejudice.
It also belongs to the larger history of the Great Migration and of Mexican labor migration, and to the friction those movements met in the industrial North during the 1920s. The people ordered to leave Johnstown were part of a nationwide reshaping of where Americans lived and worked, and the hostility they faced was part of that same national story.
Finally, the episode is a testament to the power of the Black press and of activist journalism. Long before civil rights victories reshaped the law, reporters and organizers used the written word to force injustice into the open, to summon investigations, and to shift public opinion. Remembering Rosedale honors both the people who were wronged and those who made sure the wrong was recorded.
If you visit
You're in East Taylor Township, in the hills and river valleys of Cambria County, near the steel town of Johnstown. This is landscape shaped by industry, and it helps to stand here and remember that the people this marker mourns came to places like this seeking work and a better life.
This is a somber stop, and it asks for reflection rather than sightseeing. Read the inscription and sit with the scale of it—thousands of people told to leave under threat of jail in a single order. Markers that name painful history do so precisely so that it is not forgotten.
If your travels take you through the Johnstown area, let this be a place to slow down and consider the whole of the region's past—not only its famous floods and its steel, but the human costs borne by its newest residents in the 1920s. The most fitting thing you can bring away is the resolve to learn the fuller story.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · Joseph Cauffiel
Related events
- · Rosedale Banishment
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
Escape of Freedom Seekers Patrick and Abraham
Geistown, PA · est. 2014
In February 1837, brothers Patrick and Abraham escaped enslavement on a farm in Bath, Virginia, and fled north toward freedom as bounty hunters pursued and wounded them. In Pennsylvania both Black and white abolitionists came to their aid, including William Slick, whose farm near here was a regular stop on the Underground Railroad. Though the brothers were seized in Johnstown, they slipped away without trial or recapture.
Benjamin Walker Homestead
West Saint Clair Township, PA · est. 2006
In the tense years before and during the Civil War, the Walker Homestead in Bedford County served as a vital station on the Underground Railroad, perilously close to the Maryland line and the reach of slave catchers. Benjamin Walker, Abner Walker, Sr., and George Harbaugh worked hand in hand with African American conductors John Fiddler, Elisa Rouse, and Joseph Crawley, guiding hundreds of freedom seekers from the Pennsylvania border across the mountains and northward toward liberty.
Fugitive Slave Rescue
Blairsville, PA · est. 2004
In April 1858, with the Fugitive Slave Act empowering federal marshals and Southern slave-catchers to reach deep into the free states, the people of Blairsville acted. They rescued a man named Newman from arrest, and local Black abolitionist Lewis Johnson—a conductor on the Underground Railroad—sheltered him. Indiana County had long been an important station on the secret routes north.
Dr. Robert Mitchell (1786-1863)
Clymer, PA · est. 2007
Dr. Robert Mitchell of Indiana County was an outspoken abolitionist who, in September 1845, sheltered five people fleeing slavery on his property here. When bounty hunters raided, two escaped but three were dragged back into bondage—and Mitchell was tried, convicted, and financially ruined for violating the Fugitive Slave Act of 1793. His case fed the national controversy that hardened into the harsher Fugitive Slave Act of 1850.