Sholar Cemetery
Tenaha, Shelby County, Texas
Marker Inscription
Several families from Henry County, Alabama, settled in this area in 1846, including the John and Nancy (Kirkland) Scott family. Their son William sold his brother-in-law David Sholar 111 acres here in 1850. This site became a burial ground in the summer of 1854 with the deaths of six cousins, ages one to ten, likely from the same illness. Truitt's Chapel later organized across the road, and the Sholar post office operated from 1906-15. The nearby community of Eagle Mills was also associated with this cemetery. Veterans of military conflicts dating back to the U.S-Mexico War are buried here, along with ancestors of several area families. Masonic Lodge and Woodmen of the World gravestones are also prominent.Historic Texas Cemetery-2007
Erected by Texas Historical Commission
The Story
Families from Henry County, Alabama, settled this Shelby County land in 1846, and the ground became a cemetery in 1854 when six young cousins died within a single summer, likely of the same illness. A chapel, a post office, and the community of Eagle Mills grew up around it. Veterans of conflicts reaching back to the U.S.-Mexico War lie here, their graves marked by prominent Masonic and Woodmen of the World stones.
Why it matters
The cemetery preserves the story of an antebellum migration from the Deep South into East Texas and the tight-knit farming community it produced.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
This Shelby County burial ground was born of the great mid-nineteenth-century migration that carried families out of the Deep South and into the piney woods of East Texas. In the 1840s, Texas was fresh American country, and settlers from states like Alabama were pulling up stakes and moving west in search of land, often traveling as whole networks of kin and neighbors rather than as lone households.
The result was a distinctively close-knit kind of community. Families arrived together, married into one another, bought and sold land among themselves, and — inevitably — buried their dead together. Life in this era and this place was rural and precarious: prosperity depended on the land, and survival depended on neighbors, especially when illness swept through, as it so often did before modern medicine.
The periods this site spans — the early Republic-era frontier and the Civil War years that followed — were the formative decades of East Texas. This cemetery preserves the memory of one such community as it took root, grew, and endured.
People & events
The community's story here begins in 1846, when several families from Henry County, Alabama, settled in the area — among them John and Nancy Scott and their kin. In 1850, their son William sold 111 acres of this land to his brother-in-law, David Sholar, and the ground that bears Sholar's name entered the historical record.
Its life as a burial place began in heartbreak. In the summer of 1854, six young cousins — children ranging from one to ten years old — died, most likely of the same illness sweeping through the family. To lose six children of one extended family in a single season is a grief almost impossible to fathom, and it was that loss that first consecrated this ground. The cemetery's very origin is a reminder of how fragile childhood was on the frontier, and how tightly disease could grip a close community.
Around the burial ground, a fuller community grew. Truitt's Chapel was later organized across the road; the Sholar post office operated from 1906 to 1915; and the nearby community of Eagle Mills was tied to the cemetery as well. The graves gathered veterans of America's conflicts reaching back to the U.S.–Mexico War, along with the ancestors of many local families. Among the stones, the emblems of the Masonic Lodge and the Woodmen of the World stand out — signs of the fraternal orders that bound these rural neighbors together in life as well as in death.
Its place in the American story
The Sholar Cemetery preserves a quintessentially American story: the westward movement of families from the older Southern states into new frontier country, and the tight-knit communities they built there. The migration from places like Henry County, Alabama, into East Texas was repeated thousands of times over across the nineteenth century, and it is the human engine behind the settlement of the region.
The veterans resting here — from the U.S.–Mexico War forward — tie this quiet plot to the broader sweep of American military history, and to the way even the most remote farming communities sent their sons to the nation's conflicts. A rural cemetery is often the only place where that service is permanently recorded.
The fraternal emblems carry a national theme of their own. In an age before government safety nets, orders like the Masons and the Woodmen of the World offered fellowship, mutual aid, and — through the Woodmen's distinctive tree-stump and log monuments — a dignified burial. Their prominence here reflects a nationwide feature of American community life in this period, visible in the stones themselves.
If you visit
Walk this cemetery slowly and let its markers tell you about the people who built the community around it. Look for the distinctive fraternal gravestones — the emblems of the Masonic Lodge and the carved motifs of the Woodmen of the World — which were badges of belonging in a time when such orders were the heart of rural social life.
The most affecting part of any visit is the beginning of the story: the graves that date to that terrible summer of 1854, when six young cousins were lost together. Standing among them, you feel the vulnerability of frontier childhood in a way no history book conveys. Nearby lie veterans whose service stretches back to the U.S.–Mexico War, and the ancestors of families still tied to this land.
Though the post office is long closed and the surrounding community has thinned, the cemetery endures as the keeper of their memory. Come as you would to any active burial ground — quietly and with respect — and read it as a record of an Alabama-to-Texas migration and the close, resilient community it planted in the East Texas woods.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · David Sholar
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
James Rowe
Old Center, TX
James Rowe came to the Mexican frontier of Texas from North Carolina and took up arms in the 1836 revolution that won Texas its independence. A prosperous tanner, he helped organize newly created Panola County in 1846, served a term in the young state's legislature, and donated the ground where this cemetery now stands. His story is a compact portrait of the settler-soldiers who turned a contested borderland into an American state.
Ramah Cemetery
Tenaha, TX
The Ramah community grew from the 1870s homestead of William Tell and Mollie Pou, who helped found Ramah Baptist Church in 1874 and gave its name — a biblical 'high place' — to the settlement's log church, school, store, and cotton gin. The cemetery formally deeded in 1909 holds more than a thousand graves, including over a hundred veterans spanning the U.S.-Mexican War through the Korean Conflict. Among them lies George E.B. Peddy, elected to the legislature while still a University of Texas student and a two-time U.S. Senate candidate decorated in both World Wars.
Shelby County
Center, TX
This corner of East Texas lay within the lawless 'neutral ground' between 1803 and 1819 before Anglo-American settlement began in the 1820s, first organized as the district and then municipality of Tenehaw. Renamed in 1836 to honor Revolutionary War officer Isaac Shelby, the county sent delegates to Texas's early conventions and soldiers to San Jacinto, and its seat moved from Shelbyville to Center in 1866. From 1841 to 1844 it was torn by the Regulator-Moderator Feud, a bloody vigilante conflict finally ended when Republic of Texas troops under Gen. James Smith restored order.
Anderson Cemetery
Carthage, TX
On a tree-shaded hill southeast of Carthage lies the burial place of many of Panola County's founding settlers, named for Jonathan Anderson (1798–1890), who donated 100 acres for the town itself. A veteran of the Texas Revolution who fought at the Siege of Bexar and the Battle of San Jacinto, Anderson went on to serve as county sheriff. His first wife, Nancy Whetmore, was the first laid to rest here, followed by veterans of the Civil War and both World Wars.