First Cumberland Presbyterian Church of Austin
Austin, Travis County, Texas
Marker Inscription
In 1853, Missionary Rev. E.B. Crisman formally organized the Cumberland Presbyterian Church in Austin. Members met in a frame building at 7th and Lavaca streets until 1892, when they replaced it with a stone structure. In 1906, a dispute over a church merger that led all the way to the Texas Supreme Court forced the Cumberland members to move and turn their building over to the Presbyterian USA church. Eight years later,through elder R.M. Castleman, the congregation was able to buy back its building. Around 1950, members built a new sanctuary at this location. The First Cumberland Presbyterian Church of Austin celebrated its 150th year in 2003. (2005)
Erected by Texas Historical Commission
The Story
The First Cumberland Presbyterian Church of Austin was organized in 1853 by missionary Rev. E.B. Crisman, meeting first in a frame building downtown before raising a stone structure in 1892. A bitter dispute over a denominational merger reached the Texas Supreme Court in 1906 and cost the Cumberland members their building, but through elder R.M. Castleman they bought it back eight years later. Around 1950 they built a new sanctuary and, in 2003, marked 150 years of continuous worship.
Why it matters
Its courthouse fight over a church merger shows how the national schisms of American Presbyterianism played out congregation by congregation, testing the resolve of local believers.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
In 1853 Austin was a modest capital city on the Colorado River, the seat of government of a state that had joined the Union only eight years earlier. Settlers were pouring into Central Texas from the older Southern states, and they brought their churches with them. Missionary preachers rode out to organize congregations wherever enough families had gathered.
The Cumberland Presbyterian Church was one of those transplanted traditions. It began on the Tennessee and Kentucky frontier in the early 1800s, in the fervor of the revivals of that era. It broke from the main Presbyterian body over questions of strict predestination and of whether frontier preachers needed full classical education to be ordained. Its warmer, revival-friendly style suited the frontier, and it spread widely across the South and West, including Texas.
By the early twentieth century, the two Presbyterian bodies were negotiating a reunion. A union was approved in 1906, but many Cumberland members refused to join it. That disagreement turned into a wave of disputes over who owned church buildings, and congregations across several states, including in Texas, found themselves in court.
People & events
The story opens with a missionary, the Rev. E. B. Crisman, who formally organized Austin's Cumberland Presbyterian Church in 1853. Members gathered in a frame building at 7th and Lavaca streets, just a few blocks from the heart of the capital. In 1892, confident and growing, they replaced it with a sturdier stone church.
Then came the crisis. In 1906 the dispute over the denominational merger reached all the way to the Texas Supreme Court, and the outcome forced the Cumberland loyalists to leave and turn their stone building over to the Presbyterian Church in the USA. Imagine walking away from a sanctuary your own congregation had built barely fourteen years before.
The congregation did not dissolve. Eight years later, through the efforts of elder R. M. Castleman, members were able to buy their building back. It must have felt like a homecoming.
Around 1950 the church moved again, this time by choice, building a new sanctuary at its present location. In 2003 the congregation celebrated 150 years. That is a century and a half of history that includes losing its home in court and winning it back through persistence.
Its place in the American story
Austin's Cumberland Presbyterians lived through a story that played out in towns all over the country. When national church bodies merged or split, the hardest questions landed at the local level. Who owned the pews, the pulpit and the deed to the lot? American courts were repeatedly asked to settle these questions, and the cases helped shape how the law treats property disputes inside religious bodies.
The congregation's endurance also shows something about American religious life. Even when a denomination's leadership chose union, many ordinary members held fast to the identity they had inherited. They were willing to start over rather than give it up. The Cumberland Presbyterian Church continued as a separate denomination after 1906 because of congregations like this one.
And the church's journey through Austin, from a downtown frame building to stone and then to a newer neighborhood in the mid-twentieth century, mirrors the growth of the capital itself from frontier seat of government to a modern city.
If you visit
Today's sanctuary dates from around 1950, so don't expect a pioneer-era building at this site. The deeper history lives in the congregation's story. If you are exploring downtown Austin, you can stand near 7th and Lavaca streets and imagine the frame church, and later the stone church, that once stood in that part of the city, close to the Capitol grounds.
This is an active church, so be respectful of services and private spaces. The marker itself is the best place to pause and take in the remarkable sequence of the story: organized, built, lost, regained and moved.
It makes a thoughtful stop on a day of exploring Austin's history, alongside the Texas State Capitol and the city's other historic churches. For families, it is a good conversation starter about how people stick together through hard times.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · Rev. E.B. Crisman
- · R.M. Castleman
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
Old Quarry Site
Austin, TX
Limestone cut from this quarry was hauled by ox teams to Congress Avenue to build the 1853 Texas Capitol, one of Austin's first monumental public buildings. When that statehouse burned in 1881, stone salvaged from its ruins found new life in later Austin construction. The land itself had been granted to Tennessee native George Washington Davis for his service in the Texas Revolution and long remained the Davis family homestead.
Davis Cemetery
Austin, TX
George W. Davis brought his family to Texas in 1835, on the eve of revolution. He fought in Captain Mosely Baker's company at the Battle of San Jacinto while his wife Emiline sheltered their children on the Sabine River during the Runaway Scrape. Davis received a large land patent in 1841 and built a home near this burial ground, which holds Davis family members and neighbors and is still cared for by descendants.
Austin Memorial Park Cemetery
Austin, TX
As Austin outgrew its older graveyards in the early 20th century, a private corporation bought farmland northwest of town in 1927 and opened Austin Memorial Park, recording its first burial in 1928. The city bought the grounds in 1941 to serve the public, though highways, a recreation center, and new construction later trimmed its edges. Among those interred are Pulitzer-winning novelist James A. Michener, legendary Texas Ranger Frank Hamer, actor Zachary Scott, and famed University of Texas coaches Dana X. Bible and Harvey Penick.
Moore-Hancock Farmstead
Austin, TX
Around 1850 the Irish-born merchant Martin Moore and his wife Elizabeth left their Austin business for a 521-acre farm north of town, raising five children in the log structures they built here. After Martin's death, Elizabeth sold the homestead in 1866 to Judge John Hancock, and it is believed his formerly enslaved man Orange and family lived on the land in the late 1860s. The sensitively restored cabins survive as a rare example of local pioneer farmstead architecture.