The Alexander Carmichael House“To Catch a Spy”
Morristown, Morris County, New Jersey
Marker Inscription
The Alexander Carmichael House located on the corner of South Street and the Green at what is now 42 Park Place, was occupied by General Nathaniel Greene. Colonel Alexander Hamilton met there with a suspected spy. He had prepared an exaggerated Table of S… transcription continues on the marker
This transcription may be incomplete
Our source stores marker text in a field capped at 255 characters, and this inscription appears to have been cut off. We won’t guess at the missing words — the inscription is the primary source, and inventing it would be worse than leaving it short.
Have you stood in front of this marker? Send us the full text or a photo of the sign and we’ll complete the record.
The Story
During the Continental Army's hard winters at Morristown, this house on the corner of South Street served as quarters for General Nathanael Greene, one of Washington's most trusted commanders. The marker recalls a moment of Revolutionary intrigue: Colonel Alexander Hamilton meeting here in connection with a suspected spy, reportedly preparing a deliberately inflated tally of American strength to deceive the enemy. Such deception was a real weapon of the war, used to make a ragged, undersupplied army look far more formidable than it was.
Why it matters
It captures the cloak-and-dagger side of the Revolution, where intelligence and misinformation could matter as much as muskets in keeping the fragile American cause alive.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
Morristown, New Jersey, holds a special place in the story of the American Revolution. Its hills and its position gave the Continental Army a defensible place to wait out the winter, close enough to keep an eye on the enemy in the New York area but protected from a sudden attack. Twice during the war, Washington's army made its winter quarters in and around the town.
Those winters were brutal. The army was chronically short of food, clothing, pay, and supplies, and the cold tested the men as severely as any battle. Officers were quartered in the town's houses, and ordinary homes became headquarters, meeting rooms, and the nerve centers of a struggling army.
This marker sits at one of those houses, on the corner of South Street by the Green. It's a reminder that the Revolution wasn't fought only on open battlefields — much of it happened in parlors and around tables, in the anxious work of keeping an army alive and outwitting a stronger foe.
People & events
According to the marker, this house served as quarters for General Nathanael Greene — one of Washington's most capable and trusted commanders, a man the commander-in-chief leaned on repeatedly through the war. To have Greene lodged here places the house squarely inside the army's inner circle.
The marker then records a moment of genuine intrigue: Colonel Alexander Hamilton meeting at the house in connection with a suspected spy. Hamilton, still a young officer, was one of Washington's sharpest aides, trusted with sensitive and confidential work. The detail the marker preserves is that he had prepared an exaggerated tally of American strength — a deliberately inflated "Table of Strength."
The purpose of such a document was deception. If a spy or an enemy sympathizer could be fed numbers making the American forces look far larger and better supplied than they truly were, the misinformation might travel back to the enemy and shape their caution. It's a small scene, but a telling one: two of the Revolution's notable figures using a piece of paper as a weapon.
Its place in the American story
The image we inherit of the Revolution tends toward muskets and battle lines, but victory also depended on information — and on controlling what the enemy believed. A ragged, undersupplied army had every reason to appear stronger than it was, and deception was a real and deliberate tool for doing so.
That's what makes this marker resonate beyond Morristown. It captures the intelligence war running quietly alongside the shooting war: spies and counter-spies, planted rumors, and carefully cooked figures meant to mislead. Making a weak force look formidable could buy the time and hesitation the American cause so badly needed.
It also reminds us how young and improvised the whole effort was. Figures like Hamilton, later giants of the new nation, were here doing the unglamorous, essential work of keeping a fragile army in the field through one more hard winter.
If you visit
You'll find the site at the corner of South Street and the Green, in the heart of Morristown. Much of the drama here is invisible — it lives in the marker's words — so read it carefully and let it reframe the ordinary corner in front of you as a place where Revolutionary intrigue actually unfolded.
Morristown rewards this kind of visiting. The town and its surroundings are steeped in the army's winter encampments, so a stop here fits naturally into a wider day of Revolutionary War history in the area. Walk the Green, take in the scale of the town, and imagine officers hurrying between headquarters in the cold.
Most of all, savor the specific story this marker keeps alive: a trusted general lodged in the house, a clever young colonel, and a sheet of inflated numbers meant to fool a spy. It's the cloak-and-dagger side of the Revolution, preserved on a single street corner.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · Nathanael Greene
- · Alexander Hamilton
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
The Alliance
Morristown, NJ
In the spring of 1780, Morristown was the winter headquarters of the Continental Army, where Washington's troops endured one of the harshest seasons of the war. It was here that the young Marquis de Lafayette, newly returned from France, brought word to Washington and his aide-de-camp Alexander Hamilton that a French expeditionary force of soldiers and warships was sailing to join the American cause. That alliance, forged after the American victory at Saratoga, transformed a struggling colonial rebellion into an international war that France now openly backed with men, money, and its navy.
Arnold Tavern
Morristown, NJ
During the bleak winter after his daring victories at Trenton and Princeton, George Washington made Morristown a refuge for the Continental Army, and Colonel Jacob Arnold's tavern served as his headquarters from January to May of 1777. While the general planned from the tavern on the town green, his troops encamped in the nearby Lowantica Valley, rebuilding an army worn thin by the campaign. Morristown's hills and distance from British-held New York made it a natural stronghold in the middle years of the war.
Continental Army Encampment
Morristown, NJ
Through the winter of 1779–1780, the Continental Army made its main encampment around Morristown, New Jersey — a season of brutal cold and short supplies remembered as even harsher than Valley Forge. Among the officers wintering here was Brigadier General Henry Knox, George Washington's trusted chief of artillery. This marker recalls that grim, pivotal season when the army held together against long odds.
Thomas Paine 1737-1809
Morristown, NJ
Thomas Paine was the pamphleteer whose words helped turn a colonial rebellion into a revolution. His American Crisis series, begun in the dark winter of 1776, opened with the immortal line about times that try men's souls and was read aloud to Washington's cold, discouraged troops across New Jersey's Revolutionary landscape. An Englishman by birth who later became a French citizen and an adopted American, Paine went on to write Rights of Man and The Age of Reason, works that carried the era's arguments about liberty and reason far beyond the new nation's borders.