Stony Ridge Convention
Silver Spring Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
Marker Inscription
Located at this site, James Bell's tavern was a meeting place for Anti-Federalists. Members of the Anti-Federalist movement from the Cumberland frontier, led by Robert Whitehill, met in 1788 to oppose the US Constitution, because it lacked guarantees for individual liberties and states' rights. They demanded amendments. This meeting is linked to the adoption of the Bill of Rights and the founding of the Democratic-Republican Party.
Erected by Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission
The Story
At James Bell's tavern on this ground, Anti-Federalists from the Cumberland frontier gathered in 1788 under the leadership of Robert Whitehill to voice their opposition to the newly drafted U.S. Constitution. They objected that it lacked protections for individual liberties and the rights of the states, and they pressed for amendments. Their demands are tied to the eventual adoption of the Bill of Rights and to the rise of the Democratic-Republican Party.
Why it matters
This frontier gathering is a reminder that the Bill of Rights was won by insistent grassroots pressure, and that the young republic's political parties grew out of exactly such fights over liberty and power.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
In 1788 the United States did not yet quite exist as we know it. The Constitution had been drafted in Philadelphia the summer before, and across the states people were fiercely debating whether to ratify it. Pennsylvania was one of the great battlegrounds, and the fight there was sharp between Federalists, concentrated in Philadelphia and the commercial east, and Anti-Federalists, strong in the rural west.
Cumberland County was frontier country then — the edge of settled Pennsylvania, a landscape of farms, taverns, and hard-working families who had learned self-reliance the hard way. People here were deeply suspicious of distant, powerful government. They had come out from under British rule barely a decade before, and the memory of far-off authority overriding local liberty was fresh and personal.
A tavern like James Bell's was the natural place for such politics. On the frontier the tavern was town hall, newspaper, and meeting house all at once — where men gathered to argue, read the latest broadsides, and decide what their community would demand. It's fitting that a fight over the nation's founding charter would play out over a tavern table.
People & events
Here, at James Bell's tavern, Anti-Federalists from the Cumberland frontier gathered in 1788 to make their opposition known. Their leader was Robert Whitehill, a determined western Pennsylvanian who had already made himself a persistent voice against ratifying the Constitution as written.
Their objection was not that the country needed no government, but that this government came without a promise. The proposed Constitution, they argued, lacked guarantees for individual liberties and for the rights of the states — no plain, written assurance that freedoms of conscience, speech, and person would be protected against federal power. So they did not merely complain; they demanded amendments, insisting that the charter be corrected before it could be trusted.
That demand is the thread that ties this frontier meeting to the larger national outcome. The pressure that Whitehill and men like him applied — in taverns, petitions, and ratifying conventions across the country — helped make it politically necessary to add what became the Bill of Rights. And the coalition of those who distrusted concentrated federal power fed directly into the rise of the Democratic-Republican Party, one of the first great popular parties in American history.
Its place in the American story
It's easy to imagine the Bill of Rights as a gift handed down by the framers. This place tells a truer story: those first ten amendments were won by insistent, organized pressure from ordinary Americans who refused to ratify a government on trust alone.
The men who met on this ground were not the celebrated names of the founding. They were frontier farmers and local leaders. Yet their conviction — that liberty must be written down, not merely assumed — became a permanent feature of the American system. Every time a citizen invokes freedom of speech or the right to due process, they are standing on ground these people helped clear.
The meeting also marks a beginning in American political life: the emergence of organized parties born out of genuine disagreement over how much power a central government should hold. That argument never really ended. It runs straight through American history to the present, which is exactly why a modest gathering at a Cumberland County tavern still matters.
If you visit
This is a place that rewards imagination more than sightseeing. Stand at the marker and picture the tavern that once stood here — a plain frontier building, its main room crowded and loud, men in from surrounding farms to argue the future of a country only a few years old.
Let the setting do its work. This was the western edge of settlement in 1788, and even today the Cumberland Valley keeps a rural, open feel that helps you sense how far this was from Philadelphia's halls of power. That distance was the whole point: the people here were determined that a government made in a faraway city would not forget them.
It makes a thoughtful stop on any trip through south-central Pennsylvania's rich Revolutionary and early-republic history. Read the inscription slowly, and carry one idea back to the car with you — that the freedoms many Americans take for granted were, in part, demanded from ground like this by people whose names most of us never learned.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · Robert Whitehill
- · James Bell
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
Bethel A.M.E. Church
Carlisle, PA · est. 2009
Founded around 1820, Bethel A.M.E. was among the first African American congregations west of the Susquehanna, taking root as free Black communities built their own institutions in the early republic. The church became a station on the Underground Railroad, and its members included abolitionists John Peck and John B. Vashon, while national A.M.E. leaders like Bishop Daniel Payne were tied to its life. Here faith and the freedom struggle were inseparable.
Daniel Kaufman
South Middleton Township, PA · est. 2002
For more than a decade beginning in 1835, Daniel Kaufman risked ruin to help enslaved people fleeing north through Cumberland County. His barn and the dense woods nearby sheltered fugitives to whom he gave food and transport. In 1852 a Maryland slaveholder won a widely watched lawsuit against him, and Kaufman was fined the enormous sum of $4,000 for his defiance of the Fugitive Slave Law. He also founded the village of Boiling Springs.
Robert Whitehill (1735-1813)
Camp Hill, PA · est. 1991
Robert Whitehill settled on this land in Lowther Manor, conveyed by the Penn family in 1771, and became one of Pennsylvania's most persistent voices for popular rights. A drafter of the radical 1776 state constitution, he led the Anti-Federalist minority at the 1787 convention that ratified the U.S. Constitution, pressing amendments to guard individual liberties that were later echoed in the Bill of Rights, and he served in the legislature, the executive council, and Congress.
Genevieve Blatt
Harrisburg, PA · est. 2000
Genevieve Blatt broke barrier after barrier in 20th-century Pennsylvania politics, becoming the first woman elected to statewide office as Secretary of Internal Affairs and the first woman a major party nominated for a U.S. Senate seat in the state. Elected to the Commonwealth Court in 1973, she authored the 1975 opinion that opened school sports to girls on equal terms. She made her home at 115 North Street in Harrisburg for a quarter century.