Outlaws Benjamin Bickerstaff and Josiah Thompson
Alvarado, Johnson County, Texas
Marker Inscription
Near this site in 1869, Alvarado citizens ended the lives of outlaws Benjamin Bickerstaff and Josiah Thompson. A former Confederate veteran and prisoner of war, Bickerstaff was wanted for the murder of an African American man in Louisiana shortly after the Civil War. He later joined Alvarado business owner Josiah Thompson, also a Confederate veteran, and the two are believed to have participated in numerous robberies and murders in this area, including incidents in Alvarado. When they rode together into town on April 5, 1869, organized citizens shot them numerous times. They were buried in Balch (Old Alvarado) Cemetery. (2006)
Erected by Texas Historical Commission
The Story
In the unsettled years after the Civil War, this stretch of Johnson County was plagued by outlaws, among them Benjamin Bickerstaff, a former Confederate soldier wanted for murder in Louisiana, and his associate Josiah Thompson. When the pair rode into Alvarado on April 5, 1869, organized townspeople shot them dead. Both were buried in the old Alvarado cemetery.
Why it matters
The episode captures the vigilante justice and lawlessness that gripped much of Reconstruction-era Texas before formal law enforcement took hold.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
Texas in 1869 was a state in turmoil. The Civil War had ended four years earlier, but peace had not settled in. The state was still under Reconstruction and not yet fully readmitted to the Union. Formerly enslaved Texans were trying to build free lives under real danger, and federal authorities struggled to keep order across a vast, thinly policed land.
Violence was everywhere in those years. Returning Confederate veterans, some hardened or embittered by the war, came home to a shattered economy. Robbery, murder, and attacks on freedpeople were widespread, and in many counties the courts and sheriffs could not, or would not, stop them.
Johnson County, on the edge of the North Texas frontier south of Fort Worth, was no exception. Small towns like Alvarado were growing, trading, and trying to function while the law was too weak to protect them.
People & events
Benjamin Bickerstaff came out of the Civil War as a Confederate veteran and former prisoner of war. Soon after the war he was wanted for murdering an African American man in Louisiana. That crime belongs to a terrible pattern of the era, when freedpeople were often targeted with little hope of justice.
In Texas, Bickerstaff joined forces with Josiah Thompson, an Alvarado business owner and fellow Confederate veteran. The two are believed to have taken part in many robberies and murders in the area, some in Alvarado itself. That a local businessman rode with an outlaw shows how blurry the line between respectable citizen and criminal could be in those years.
On April 5, 1869, Bickerstaff and Thompson rode into Alvarado together. Townspeople had organized ahead of time, and they opened fire, hitting both men many times. The two outlaws were buried in Balch Cemetery, also known as Old Alvarado Cemetery. The killing was not a trial or a legal execution. It was citizens taking matters into their own hands.
Its place in the American story
The Alvarado shooting is a sharp example of a pattern that runs through Reconstruction history: when formal law failed, communities often turned to vigilante action. Sometimes that violence was aimed at genuine outlaws, as here. Elsewhere, the same lack of law enabled mobs and night riders to terrorize freedpeople and Unionists. The episode shows how fragile the rule of law was in the postwar South.
Bickerstaff's Louisiana crime connects this local story to one of Reconstruction's central tragedies. Emancipation promised freedom, but in the years after the war, violence against African Americans often went unpunished. A man wanted for murdering a Black man could ride free across state lines and keep committing crimes.
The story is uncomfortable, and it should be. Alvarado's citizens are remembered for ending a reign of terror, yet they did it outside any court. The tension between justice and lawlessness, between community defense and mob rule, is a lasting question in American history.
If you visit
The marker stands in Alvarado, in Johnson County, near the place where the shooting happened. Take a moment to imagine the small Reconstruction-era town, with riders coming in along dirt streets and neighbors who had decided they would wait no longer for the law.
If you want to follow the story to its end, Balch (Old Alvarado) Cemetery is where both men were buried. Visit it as you would any historic burial ground: quietly, respectfully, and without disturbing the graves.
Alvarado is a short drive south of Fort Worth, which makes it an easy stop on a North Texas history drive. It suits travelers who want to look past the Wild West myth to the harder reality of life in Texas after the Civil War.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · Benjamin Bickerstaff
- · Josiah Thompson
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
Myers Cemetery
Alvarado, TX
Samuel Houston Myers brought his wife Patsy and six children to Texas in 1851, establishing a family farm; over the following years he outlived three wives and buried several kin on the land. The cemetery's first recorded burial came in 1873 with his granddaughter Mary, and early graves include Myers himself, a traveler who drowned in Quil Miller Creek, and a formerly enslaved woman remembered as "Aunt Rachel." A darker chapter unfolded in 1880, when young Sam Houston Myers, Jr. was hanged for a murder his brother-in-law later confessed to.
Grandview Cemetery and Original Grand View Town Site
Grandview, TX
Grand View reportedly took its name in 1854 when John Whitmire exclaimed "What a Grand View!", and settler F. L. Kirtley soon donated land for a Baptist church and cemetery. The town grew with general stores, a blacksmith, and Johnson County's first Masonic lodge, though its founder James Scurlock died during the Civil War. The cemetery holds pioneers, the mysterious murdered traveler remembered only as "Annie," and an African American section including early settlers Scott and Elmira Matlock. When the railroad passed a mile away in 1881, the town migrated to the tracks and the cemetery gradually reclaimed the original site.
Meredith Hart House
Rio Vista, TX
Built in 1856 by Meredith Hart—an Indian fighter, cattleman, and Texas Ranger—this early home was raised with enslaved labor, its timbers carted by oxen from Louisiana. The hand-hewn, pegged frame used no nails, a testament to frontier craftsmanship. It stands from the last years before the Civil War, when Johnson County was still a raw edge of settlement.
Covington Cemetery
Covington, TX
Covington Cemetery grew alongside the plantations of brothers James and Philip Gathings, who moved from Mississippi in the early 1850s with their families and enslaved workers and amassed thousands of acres on the Blackland Prairie. James platted the town of Covington and, with his brother, donated land for a church and the Gathings Male and Female College. The earliest marked grave is a son-in-law killed at the Battle of Yellow Bayou in 1864, whose body James had brought home for reburial.