Major Andre
Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
Marker Inscription
For a short time in 1776, Major Andre and Lt. Despard, British prisoners of war, were detained in a tavern that stood on this site. Some years later, after an exchange and recapture, Andre was executed as a spy.
Erected by Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission
The Story
During the Revolution, Carlisle held British prisoners of war far from the fighting on the coast. For a short time in 1776, Major John Andre and Lieutenant Despard were detained in a tavern on this site. Andre was later exchanged, returned to service, and after his involvement in Benedict Arnold's treason was captured again and executed as a spy.
Why it matters
Andre's story links a quiet Pennsylvania town to one of the Revolution's most dramatic episodes of betrayal, reminding us that the war reached deep into the interior.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
In 1776 the Revolution was young, uncertain, and mostly fought along the coast — around New York, in New Jersey, up toward Canada. But the war reached inland too, in a quieter way: the interior towns became places to hold what the fighting produced, including prisoners.
Carlisle, tucked into the Cumberland Valley well west of the seaboard, was a natural choice. It was far from British lines and any hope of rescue, defensible, and already an established town with taverns, a garrison tradition, and the infrastructure to lodge men under guard. Sending captured British officers here put a long, hard march between them and their own army.
A tavern of that era was more than a bar. It was an inn, a meeting hall, and often the most substantial semi-public building around — which made it exactly the sort of place where officers awaiting exchange might be detained. On this site once stood such a tavern, and for a short time in 1776 it held two men who had crossed an ocean to fight.
People & events
The two prisoners were Major John André and Lieutenant Despard, British soldiers held here briefly after their capture. For André, this detention was only a passing episode — he was later exchanged and returned to active service, the ordinary fate of a captured officer.
What followed was anything but ordinary. Some years later André became entangled with Benedict Arnold, the American general whose name became a byword for betrayal. When Arnold's plot was exposed, André was taken a second time — no longer a uniformed prisoner of war, but a man caught behind enemy lines in circumstances the American command judged to be spying.
That distinction cost him his life. He was tried and executed as a spy, a death that drew unusual sympathy even from those who condemned it, because André was widely regarded as a capable and honorable young officer caught in a dishonorable scheme. The tavern that once stood here held him at the very start of that arc, long before anyone could have guessed how it would end.
Its place in the American story
Arnold's treason is one of the Revolution's most famous episodes precisely because it cut so close to disaster: a trusted American general nearly handed a key position to the enemy. André's fate is the human hinge of that story, and it turned on the razor's edge between being a prisoner of war and being a spy.
This site connects a quiet Pennsylvania valley to that national drama. It reminds us that the men who would later stand at the center of the war's greatest scandal had first passed through ordinary places — marched inland, held in a tavern, exchanged like any other captured officer.
It also corrects a common picture of the Revolution as a coastal affair. The war's reach ran deep into the interior, and towns far from any battlefield played their own part — as prisons, supply points, and waystations in a conflict that touched far more of the country than the famous battle sites suggest.
If you visit
There's nothing dramatic to see here, and that's the point. The tavern is long gone; what remains is the ground it stood on and a marker that asks you to imagine it. Read it and picture a working inn on a valley street, and two foreign officers waiting inside under guard.
Carlisle's historic center makes that act of imagination easier. The town has kept its old street pattern and much of its early character, so it's not hard to feel the scale of the 18th-century place — small, close, a long way from anywhere a rescue could come from.
Make this one stop on a Revolutionary-era loop through Carlisle. Standing where a future footnote-turned-legend was once briefly held is a good way to remember that the war's most famous names all started as ordinary soldiers, passing through ordinary towns.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Plan your visit
NearbyMake a day of it — museums, food, and places to stay near this marker.
Museums & culture
- Appalachian Trail Museum13.0 mi away
- Ye Olde Sulphur Spa Historical Society13.5 mi away
Places data © OpenStreetMap contributors. Hours and details change — call ahead.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · Major John Andre
- · Lieutenant Despard
- · Benedict Arnold
Related events
- · American Revolution
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
Blaine House
Carlisle, PA · est. 1949
This site held the home of General Ephraim Blaine, who as Commissary General kept the Continental Army fed through some of the Revolution's hardest campaigns — a thankless logistical task on which victory quietly depended. Years later, in October 1794, Blaine hosted President George Washington for a week here while Washington gathered a militia army at Carlisle to march against the Whiskey Rebellion in western Pennsylvania. It is a rare double witness to the war for independence and the young republic's first great test of federal authority.
Thompson's Rifle Battalion
Carlisle, PA · est. 1986
When Congress moved to build a Continental force in June 1775, it authorized its very first battalion — nine companies of riflemen raised here in the Pennsylvania backcountry under Col. William Thompson of Carlisle. These frontier marksmen marched to join the siege of Boston, and the unit later became the First Pennsylvania Continental Regiment. Their muster placed Carlisle at the founding of the American army.
Molly Pitcher
Carlisle, PA · est. 1949
Mary Hays McCauley, remembered in legend as "Molly Pitcher," became one of the Revolution's most enduring heroines for her courage at the Battle of Monmouth in 1778, where women carried water to overheated soldiers and, by tradition, she took a place at the cannon. She is buried in the Old Graveyard just east of here, among many of Carlisle's distinguished early citizens.
First Presbyterian Church
Carlisle, PA · est. 1949
Begun in 1757 and reckoned the oldest public building in Carlisle, the First Presbyterian Church grew from a congregation organized at Meeting House Springs back in 1734. Its walls witnessed history twice over: in 1774 townspeople gathered here to declare for American independence, and in 1794 President George Washington worshipped within them while rallying troops against the Whiskey Rebellion. Stone-built and enduring, it stands at the civic heart of the old frontier town.