First Methodist Church
Frankfort, Franklin County, Kentucky
Marker Inscription
First Methodist Church. Organized by Rev. William Holman in 1821. First Methodist Conference in Kentucky, 1790, made Frankfort, then a frontier station, part of the Lexington Circuit. The first small church built on Ann Steet. Present site of church purchased, 1856; building completed, 1858. Bishops H. H. Kavanaugh and E. L. Tullis served as pastors of church. Presented by John B. Browning Memorial Class.
Erected by Kentucky Historical Society
The Story
Methodism reached Kentucky when it was still raw frontier: the first conference in 1790 folded Frankfort, then a frontier station, into the sprawling Lexington Circuit ridden by itinerant preachers. A settled Frankfort congregation was organized in 1821 by the Rev. William Holman, worshipping first in a small church on Ann Street before buying the present site in 1856 and completing its building in 1858. Two of its pastors, H. H. Kavanaugh and E. L. Tullis, rose to become bishops.
Why it matters
It traces the spread of frontier Methodism from circuit-riding preachers into a permanent town church — a pattern that carried organized religion across the trans-Appalachian West.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
When Methodism first reached Kentucky, this was the edge of the American map. In 1790 the Ohio Valley was still raw frontier — a country of trace roads, blockhouses, and scattered stations where families lived within reach of a fort. Frankfort itself was one of those frontier stations, newly laid out along a bend of the Kentucky River, far from the settled coast where most Americans still lived.
Into that country rode the circuit preachers. Early Methodism spread not by building churches first but by sending itinerant ministers on horseback to ride enormous loops through the wilderness, preaching in cabins, clearings, and courthouses. To fold a place like Frankfort into the Lexington Circuit was to promise it a preacher on a schedule — a thread of organized faith stitched across a landscape that had almost none.
By the 1820s, the frontier phase was passing. Kentucky had become a state, Frankfort its capital, and the loose circuit was giving way to settled congregations with their own buildings and pastors. The church remembered on this marker grew up exactly in that transition, as a wilderness mission matured into a town institution.
People & events
The story begins a full generation before the congregation itself. In 1790 the first Methodist conference in Kentucky placed Frankfort within the sprawling Lexington Circuit — meaning the town's earliest Methodists were served by traveling preachers rather than a settled minister of their own.
That changed in 1821, when the Rev. William Holman organized a permanent congregation in Frankfort. Its first home was a small church on Ann Street — modest quarters for a young flock. As the congregation grew, it looked for something more lasting: the present site was purchased in 1856, and the building was completed in 1858, on the eve of the nation's great crisis.
What makes this congregation's history remarkable is the caliber of ministers who passed through its pulpit. Two of its pastors, H. H. Kavanaugh and E. L. Tullis, went on to become bishops of the church — a reminder that a capital-city congregation, however it began, could send its leaders to the highest ranks of American Methodism.
Its place in the American story
The arc traced here — from circuit rider to settled sanctuary — is one of the great untold engines of American expansion. As the young republic pushed west across the Appalachians, organized religion followed not by accident but by design, and Methodism's mobile, horseback ministry was extraordinarily good at keeping pace with the frontier.
Wherever settlers went, the circuit preacher soon arrived, and behind him came the small first church, then the permanent building, then the congregation that anchored a community's civic life. Multiply this Frankfort story by thousands of towns across the trans-Appalachian West and you have one of the ways a scattered frontier became a settled society.
That a congregation could rise from a small frontier station to send bishops into national church leadership also shows how quickly the American interior stopped being a periphery. The West did not merely receive institutions from the East; within a generation it was producing leaders of its own.
If you visit
Stand in front of the church and let the dates do their work. The congregation was organized in 1821, but the building you're looking at was completed in 1858 — so you're seeing the settled, confident second act of a story that began with a preacher on horseback and a tiny frame church on Ann Street.
Frankfort is a compact, walkable capital, and this marker sits comfortably within a day of exploring Kentucky's seat of government. Pair it with the old statehouse and the riverfront to feel how a frontier river town grew into a capital, with its churches maturing right alongside it.
As you look up at the mid-19th-century architecture, remember the two future bishops who once preached here. It's an easy thing to forget standing on a quiet street, but this modest congregation was a training ground for leaders whose influence reached far beyond Kentucky.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · William Holman
- · H. H. Kavanaugh
- · E. L. Tullis
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
First Methodist Church, Frankfort
Frankfort, KY
Methodism reached Frankfort early: the 1790 conference folded the then-frontier station into the Lexington Circuit, and by 1821 Rev. William Holman had organized the town's First Methodist congregation, whose first small church stood on Ann Street. The present site was purchased in 1856 and its building completed in 1858. Bishops H.H. Kavanaugh and E.I. Tullis both served here as pastors.
Corner in Celebrities
Frankfort, KY
This leafy quarter of old Frankfort earned its nickname from the astonishing concentration of national figures who once lived within a few blocks—among them Supreme Court justice John Marshall Harlan, statesman John J. Crittenden, senators John and James Brown, several Kentucky governors, and admiral Hugh Rodman. Over a century and more, judges, senators, diplomats, and military leaders called this small neighborhood home. Few street corners in America have sent so many of their residents into the nation's highest offices.
Justice Todd House
Frankfort, KY
Built in 1812, this was the Frankfort home of Thomas Todd, a Virginia-born jurist who served as clerk to the Danville conventions that brought Kentucky to statehood before rising through the young state's courts. President Jefferson appointed him to the U.S. Supreme Court, where he served from 1807 until his death in 1826. His second marriage, to Dolley Madison's sister Lucy Payne Washington, was the first wedding ever recorded in the White House.
Site of the Love House
Frankfort, KY
Built around 1786 by General James Wilkinson on land once owned by Aaron Burr, this house hosted the first meeting of the legislature after Frankfort became Kentucky's capital in 1793. Later purchased by Major Thomas Love, it served for years as an inn and the social and political heart of the young capital. Its guests included the exiled French prince Louis Philippe—a future king of France—and Aaron Burr himself.