HistoricSiteMarkers
Colonial America

First Brethren Baptism in America, 1723

Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania

Marker Inscription

The first baptismal service of the Church of the Brethren in America took place at this site on Christmas day 1723

The Story

On Christmas Day 1723, a small band of German immigrants gathered at the water's edge in Germantown and performed the first American baptisms of the Church of the Brethren, a pietist movement born in Schwarzenau, Germany, in 1708. Fleeing religious persecution in the Old World, these settlers had found in Pennsylvania the freedom to practice their faith — including their signature rite of full-immersion adult baptism. That winter service planted one of the earliest peace-church congregations in the American colonies.

Why it matters

It marks the American beginning of a historic peace church and stands as a testament to William Penn's colony as a haven where persecuted European sects could worship freely.

The story behind this marker

AI context

The era

In the early 1700s, Pennsylvania was the most religiously tolerant place in the English-speaking world. William Penn had founded his colony as a "holy experiment" — a haven where people could worship as their conscience demanded, without fines, prison, or exile. Word of that freedom traveled fast across a Europe still torn by the wars and persecutions that followed the Reformation, and it drew boatloads of German-speaking dissenters to the Delaware Valley.

Many of them landed in Germantown, a settlement founded in 1683 just north of Philadelphia by German and Dutch families. By the 1720s it had become the beating heart of German America — a place where you might hear more German than English on the street, and where Quakers, Mennonites, and smaller pietist groups lived side by side.

Into this world came the Brethren. Their movement had begun in 1708 in Schwarzenau, Germany, under a miller's son named Alexander Mack, who gathered a handful of believers convinced that true faith meant a freely chosen, adult commitment sealed by baptism. In their homeland that conviction was dangerous. In Pennsylvania, it was finally safe.

People & events

The first Brethren emigrants reached Pennsylvania a few years before 1723, part of the steady stream of German pietists crossing the Atlantic. Scattered and few, they spent their first American years quietly, working the land and finding their footing in a new country.

Then, on Christmas Day in 1723, they gathered at the water's edge and did the thing that had once marked them for persecution: they baptized new believers by full immersion. Leading them was Peter Becker, a weaver who would become the young congregation's first minister. That winter service organized the first Brethren congregation in America.

The rite itself explains their common nickname. Neighbors called them "Dunkers" — from the German *tunken*, to dip — because they baptized adults by plunging them entirely beneath the surface. What looked like a curiosity to onlookers was, to the Brethren, the entire point: baptism belonged to those old enough to choose it for themselves.

Its place in the American story

This quiet creekside service marks the American birth of one of the country's three historic "peace churches," alongside the Quakers and the Mennonites — communities that would become known for refusing to bear arms and for a plain, service-minded way of life. From this single Germantown congregation, the Brethren spread down the Great Wagon Road into the backcountry of Virginia and the Carolinas and, later, across the growing nation.

It is also a chapter in the larger German migration that shaped colonial America. The Pennsylvania Germans — later blurred into the term "Pennsylvania Dutch" — brought their language, farming, crafts, and faiths, and they made the middle colonies the most culturally mixed corner of British North America.

Most of all, the 1723 baptism is a small, concrete proof of Penn's grand idea. A ritual that had drawn fines and exile in Europe could be performed openly here, in daylight, without fear. Religious liberty in early America was not an abstraction; it was people standing in cold water, worshiping as they wished.

If you visit

You'll find this marker in Germantown, in the historic northwest of Philadelphia — a neighborhood layered with colonial-era stone houses and threaded by the wooded valley of the Wissahickon. It's a landscape where the eighteenth century still shows through, if you slow down enough to look for it.

Stand here and try to picture the scene in reverse season: not a summer sidewalk but a raw December morning, a small band of immigrants gathered by the water, their breath visible, choosing to be baptized in the cold. It's a memorial to a moment, so let the moment do the work — a handful of people, far from home, quietly claiming the freedom they had crossed an ocean to find.

The spot fits naturally into a day exploring Germantown's early history or a walk in the Wissahickon valley nearby. Bring good shoes, a sense of the past, and a little imagination — the best souvenirs this place offers are the ones you carry in your head.

Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.

Plan your visit

Nearby

Make a day of it — museums, food, and places to stay near this marker.

Museums & culture

Attractions

Food & drink

Places to stay

Places data © OpenStreetMap contributors. Hours and details change — call ahead.

Own a business near here? Add it to the map.

Themes & tags

ImmigrationMemorial

Nearby & related markers

Kelpius Community

Philadelphia, PA · est. 2004

In 1694 the German mystic Johannes Kelpius led a band of learned followers to the banks of the Wissahickon, drawn by William Penn's promise of religious liberty. Known as the "Hermits of the Wissahickon," they wrote poetry and music, studied the stars and plants, built one of the colonies' early pipe organs, and waited for the millennium they believed near. Notably tolerant for their age, they welcomed people of every background, including Native Americans, until the community faded after Kelpius's death in 1708.

ImmigrationEducation

Johannes Kelpius, Hermit of the Wissahickon

Philadelphia, PA

In 1694 a band of German mystics led by the young scholar Johannes Kelpius crossed the Atlantic and settled along the Wissahickon Creek near Philadelphia, awaiting what they believed would be the dawn of a new spiritual age. Learned in theology, astronomy, and music, Kelpius lived as a hermit — tradition holds he used a cave near this spot for prayer and meditation — until his death in 1708. Much later, in 1961, Rosicrucians of the AMORC order erected this memorial, claiming him as a forerunner of their movement.

Immigration

Germantown Meetinghouse

Philadelphia, PA · est. 2008

Built in 1770, this was the first meetinghouse in the nation for the Church of the Brethren, a German pietist denomination born in 1708. Facing harsh religious persecution at home, virtually the entire church pulled up roots and resettled in America by 1750, seeking the freedom of worship that Pennsylvania promised. Many of the movement's earliest American leaders rest in the cemetery here.

Immigration

Christopher Saur (1693-1758)

Philadelphia, PA · est. 2009

Christopher Saur was a pioneering printer in colonial Pennsylvania who in 1743 produced the first Bible printed in a European language in America — a German edition for the region's growing immigrant community. From his press came the most widely read German-language newspaper of the day, and he used it to champion German causes and aid fellow newcomers with his money and influence. His shop was a cornerstone of German-American life in the colonies.

ImmigrationIndustry & Invention