Early Republic

Danville Presbyterian Church

Danville, Boyle County, Kentucky

Marker Inscription

Presbyterian Church. One of three founded, 1784, by Reverend David Rice; earliest of this denomination west of Alleghenies. Here worshipped: James G. Birney, whose presidential candidacy in 1844 caused defeat of Henry Clay; John C. Breckinridge, whose 1860 candidacy resulted in election of Lincoln; Samuel D. Burchard, whose "Rum, Romanism and Rebellion" defeated James G. Blaine in 1884.

Erected by Kentucky Historical Society

The Story

Founded in 1784 by the Reverend David Rice, this was one of the earliest Presbyterian congregations west of the Alleghenies, planted as Kentucky's frontier filled with settlers. Its pews held figures who shaped national politics: abolitionist James G. Birney, whose 1844 presidential run helped cost Henry Clay the election; John C. Breckinridge, whose 1860 candidacy split the Democrats and aided Lincoln; and Samuel D. Burchard, whose 1884 'Rum, Romanism and Rebellion' remark helped sink James G. Blaine.

Why it matters

A frontier church became an unlikely crossroads of American political history, tied to three presidential elections that turned on the men who worshipped here.

The story behind this marker

AI context

The era

In 1784, Kentucky was not yet a state but a far-flung county of Virginia, its settlements strung out beyond the Appalachian barrier that had long walled off the interior. Getting there meant a hard passage over the mountains or down the Ohio, and the people who came were building churches, courts, and towns almost from nothing in country that had very recently been contested frontier.

Religion followed the settlers west, and among the first to organize it here were the Presbyterians. This congregation in Danville was one of three founded that year by the Reverend David Rice — the earliest of that denomination west of the Alleghenies. A church was more than a place of worship on the frontier; it was one of the first institutions to give a scattered community shape, order, and a shared moral vocabulary.

Danville itself sat at the center of the movement toward Kentucky statehood. In the years after this church was founded, the town hosted a series of conventions that debated how, and whether, the district should separate from Virginia and join the Union — a process that culminated in statehood in 1792. A congregation planted in 1784 stood at the very beginning of that story.

People & events

What makes this frontier church remarkable is the roster of people who are said to have worshipped in it — men whose later lives touched three different presidential elections. The marker lists them plainly, and their stories reach far beyond Kentucky.

James G. Birney, born in Danville, freed the people he had enslaved and became a leading abolitionist, running for president in 1844 as an antislavery candidate. His campaign drew away just enough antislavery votes to help cost Henry Clay the election — a striking case of a third-party candidacy tipping a national result. John C. Breckinridge rose to become vice president of the United States and then, in 1860, a presidential candidate whose Southern Democratic campaign split his party; that division helped open the way for Abraham Lincoln's victory. Breckinridge would later serve the Confederacy.

The third name belongs to Samuel D. Burchard, a clergyman remembered for a single disastrous phrase. In 1884, speaking at a gathering that candidate James G. Blaine attended, he branded the opposition the party of "Rum, Romanism and Rebellion." Blaine failed to repudiate the insult to Catholic voters, and it is widely believed to have helped sink his campaign. Three men, three elections, one frontier congregation.

Its place in the American story

It is easy to think of national history as something that happens in Washington, made by strangers in marble halls. This modest Kentucky church tells a different story: that the currents of American politics ran through ordinary local places, and that the people who shaped presidential contests were once neighbors sharing the same pews.

The three episodes gathered here also illustrate a recurring truth about American elections — how often they turn on the margins. A third-party candidate, a fractured party, a single ill-chosen phrase: each of these, in its own year, helped decide who would lead the country. The outcomes were close enough that small things mattered enormously.

That a single frontier congregation could be linked to all three is partly coincidence and partly a reminder of how tightly connected the early republic's leadership class was. Churches, colleges, and towns like this one were the seedbeds from which national figures grew.

If you visit

Danville rewards visitors who care about where American self-government took root, and this church belongs on that itinerary. Come thinking not only about worship but about the wider community of which this congregation was a founding part.

Let the dates do their work as you stand here. A congregation begun in 1784, before Kentucky was a state, connected across the following century to national elections in 1844, 1860, and 1884 — that is a long thread of history anchored to one place. It rewards a slow, reflective visit rather than a quick photo.

Danville makes a fine stop on a road trip through Kentucky's Bluegrass country, where the story of the frontier's transformation into settled, self-governing communities is written across the landscape. Pair this site with the town's other historic corners to see how a small place can hold a large share of the national past.

Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.

Own a business near here? Add it to the map.

Related people

· David Rice
· James G. Birney
· John C. Breckinridge
· Samuel D. Burchard

Themes & tags

Westward ExpansionFrontier HistoryChurch

Nearby & related markers

Walker Daniel, Founder of Danville

Danville, KY

Walker Daniel founded Danville in 1781 and, two years later, became the first attorney general of the Kentucky District. Serving on a commission at the Falls of the Ohio, he helped allot the lands granted to George Rogers Clark's Illinois Regiment. His promising career was cut short in August 1784 when he was killed by Indians while traveling to visit his brother at Bullitt's Lick.

Westward Expansion Native American History

Grayson's Tavern

Danville, KY

Before 1800, Benjamin Grayson kept Danville's first tavern in this building, where settlers gathered before roaring log fires to argue the burning political questions of the frontier. Here in 1786 met the Danville Political Society, the first organization of its kind in the West, whose members debated the future of the region as Kentucky moved toward statehood. Such taverns were the crucibles of early western self-government.

Westward Expansion

First Presbyterian Church of Lancaster

Lancaster, KY

Organized in 1816 by the Presbytery of Transylvania with twenty-two members, this Garrard County congregation was first served by the Reverend James C. Barnes, who also ministered at nearby Paint Lick Church. Worshipers met in the shared Republican (Union) Church until 1846, built on Buford and Stanford Streets, and moved to the present site in 1879. Among its members was William O. Bradley, later a governor of Kentucky.