HistoricSiteMarkers
Reconstruction & Gilded AgeProgressive & Modern Era

Austin Avenue United Methodist Church

Waco, McLennan County, Texas

Marker Inscription

At the close of the nineteenth century, when it was determined that Waco's Fifth Street Methodist Episcopal Church, south (now First United Methodist Church) had grown too large, its members petitioned the denominaiton conference of the organization of another congregation in Waco. As a result, the quarterly conference approved the establishment of Austin Avenue Methodist Church on December 31, 1900. The Rev. John R. Nelson was appointed to organize the new congregation. Three lots were purchased at the corner of Austin Avenue and 12th street for a church building. The congregation was offically chartered on December 29, 1901, with a membership of 81,and a sanctuary was completed in April 1902. The congregation experienced a steady growth that paralleled that of its neighborhood. When the first building became too small for the growing church, it was sold to Trinity Presbyterian Church, and a new Methodist structure was built at Austin Avenue and 13th street. Throughout its history, this church has served its community with a variety of outreach programs. It continues to be an important part of Waco's history.

Erected by Texas Historical Commission

The Story

As the 19th century closed, Waco's Fifth Street Methodist congregation had simply grown too large, so in 1900 the conference approved a new church for the city. Chartered the next year with 81 members, Austin Avenue Methodist built its first sanctuary in 1902 and grew alongside its neighborhood, eventually outgrowing that home and building anew a block away. Through the decades it sustained a steady tradition of community outreach.

Why it matters

The congregation's story of division and growth mirrors the rapid expansion of Waco itself at the turn of the 20th century, when thriving churches multiplied to keep pace with booming Texas cities.

The story behind this marker

AI context

The era

At the end of the nineteenth century, Waco was a thriving Central Texas city on the Brazos River. Cotton, railroads, and commerce were driving its growth, and new residents were filling neighborhoods that spread outward from the old downtown.

As a city grows, its congregations grow with it. Waco's Fifth Street Methodist Episcopal Church, South, now First United Methodist Church, had become so large that its members decided to create another congregation. That kind of planned division was common among growing Protestant churches of the era. It was a sign of success, not conflict.

The name itself is a piece of history. The Methodist Episcopal Church, South, was the branch of Methodism formed when the denomination split along regional lines before the Civil War. Northern and Southern Methodism did not reunite until the twentieth century, a reunion that eventually produced today's United Methodist Church.

People & events

Recognizing that their church had outgrown itself, members of the Fifth Street congregation petitioned the denomination to organize a new church in Waco. The quarterly conference agreed, approving the establishment of Austin Avenue Methodist Church on December 31, 1900, the final day of the nineteenth century.

The Rev. John R. Nelson was appointed to organize the new congregation. Three lots were bought at the corner of Austin Avenue and 12th Street, and the work of building a church began. On December 29, 1901, the congregation was officially chartered with 81 members, and its sanctuary was finished in April 1902.

The congregation kept growing along with its neighborhood until the first building could no longer hold it. That building was sold to Trinity Presbyterian Church, which gave it a new life, and the Methodists built a new church at Austin Avenue and 13th Street. Through the decades the congregation has also served Waco through a range of outreach programs.

Its place in the American story

Austin Avenue's founding is a small example of a large American pattern. In the decades around 1900, cities across the country were growing fast, and churches multiplied to keep up. New congregations planted in growing neighborhoods became anchors of community life, providing places for worship, gathering, charity, and civic involvement.

The church's story also traces the larger history of American Methodism, from a parent congregation of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, to the reunified and renamed denomination of the later twentieth century. One local congregation carries in its records a sectional divide and its eventual healing.

The sale of the first building to another congregation is a reminder that American churches were often neighbors as much as rivals. Buildings passed from one denomination to another as communities grew and changed.

If you visit

The congregation's history runs along Austin Avenue, one of Waco's historic streets. Walk the blocks around 12th and 13th Streets and you can follow the church's move from its first corner to its later home a block away.

As you walk, notice how the neighborhood around you shaped the church's growth. The congregation grew as the surrounding area filled with homes and families, and the church's story is bound up with the city's.

Waco is a natural stop on a Central Texas road trip, with a historic downtown and the Brazos River close by. If you visit the church, keep in mind that it is a working congregation, and be respectful around service times.

Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.

Own a business near here? Add it to the map.

Related people

  • · John R. Nelson

Themes & tags

Nearby & related markers

Austin Avenue Methodist Church

Waco, TX

Designed by prolific Southern architect R.H. Hunt and completed in 1925, this Waco church is a substantial essay in Gothic style, its brick mass rising from a raised basement beneath a prominent bell tower. Time and misfortune reshaped it: the tower's original tracery was gone by the 1940s, and a 1954 fire forced the replacement of the sanctuary's art glass. What remains is a landmark that has weathered the ordinary accidents of a long congregational life.

Columbus Avenue Baptist Church

Waco, TX

On Christmas Eve 1900, Baptists in the fast-growing north Waco neighborhood gathered in a private home to plan a new congregation, and with twenty-three members transferred from First Baptist Church, they organized in January 1901. They worshiped in a Presbyterian church and the YMCA until raising a small frame sanctuary that October, later renaming the church for the street it stood on. Over the decades the congregation grew and reached out to students, the elderly, the deaf, soldiers at nearby camps, and the disadvantaged across the city.

First Presbyterian Church of Waco

Waco, TX

Founded in 1855 with just seventeen members and two ruling elders, the First Presbyterian Church of Waco grew alongside its frontier town, outgrowing two earlier buildings before raising the present sanctuary in 1912. Remarkably, across seventy-four years the congregation had only two ministers — Dr. Samuel A. King and Dr. Charles T. Caldwell — an unusual continuity of leadership. The church's steady history mirrors Waco's own growth from antebellum settlement to established city.

Grand Lodge of Texas, A.F. & A.M.

Waco, TX

Texas Freemasonry began with a false start in 1828, when Stephen F. Austin's petition to the Mexican Grand Lodge foundered amid political turmoil. A charter finally reached Texas through Anson Jones, who reportedly carried it during the Battle of San Jacinto, and in 1837 three lodges convened under Sam Houston to form the Grand Lodge of the Republic of Texas, with Jones as first Grand Master. After meeting in many places, the Grand Lodge settled permanently in Waco in 1902.