Aubrey First United Methodist Church
Aubrey, Denton County, Texas
Marker Inscription
IN 1858, DR. GEORGE T. KEY AND HIS FAMILY, ORIGINALLY FROM MISSOURI, MOVED TO DENTON COUNTY AND SETTLED NEAR THE PRESENT TOWN OF AUBREY. THERE THEY BUILT LOG CABINS, ONE OF WHICH WAS USED FOR A SCHOOL AND CHURCH. THE BUILDING, KNOWN AS THE KEY SCHOOL HOUSE, WAS THE HOME OF ONE OF THE FIRST METHODIST CHURCHES ESTABLISHED IN DENTON COUNTY, LATER RENAMED AUBREY METHODIST CHURCH. FOR YEARS, THE CONGREGATION OF THE AUBREY METHODIST CHURCH MET AT THE KEY SCHOOL AND IN MEMBERS’ HOMES UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF REVEREND F.V. EVANS. IN 1885, L.N. EDWARDS MADE AN ADDITION TO THE ORIGINAL TOWN PLAT OF AUBREY AND OFFERED A FREE LOT TO EACH CHURCH. THE AUBREY METHODIST CHURCH ACCEPTED THE LOTS ON THE CORNER OF PLUM AND MAPLE STREETS. ED F. BATES, A PIONEER CITIZEN OF THE COUNTY, DONATED FUNDS TO BUILD A CHURCH BUILDING AS CHURCH FUNDS WERE EXTREMELY SCARCE. CONSTRUCTION ON A WOOD-FRAME BUILDING WAS COMPLETED IN 1886. ON APRIL 14, 1918, A DEVASTATING TORNADO SWEPT THROUGH AUBREY AND DESTROYED THE CHURCH. A NEW, ONE-STORY BRICK VENEER BUILDING WAS COMPLETED IN FEBRUARY 1919. THE EXQUISITE PRE-RAPHAEL STYLE STAINED GLASS WINDOWS DEPICT STORIES OF THE CHRISTIAN FAITH AND ALLOW VIBRANT COLORS TO FILL THE SANCTUARY. IN 1968, THE CHURCH WAS RENAMED AUBREY FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH WHEN THE EVANGELICAL UNITED BRETHREN CHURCH AND THE METHODIST CHURCH COMBINED. THE CHURCH INCORPORATED AND BUILT AN ADJACENT FELLOWSHIP HALL IN 1986. FROM MEETING IN A LOG CABIN TO ENDURING A CYCLONE, THE AUBREY FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OVERCAME MANY OBSTACLES AND CONTINUES TO SERVE THE COMMUNITY.
Erected by Texas Historical Commission
The Story
In 1858 Dr. George T. Key moved his family from Missouri to Denton County and built log cabins near present-day Aubrey, one of which served as both school and church — the Key School House that cradled one of the county's first Methodist congregations. After years of meeting in the schoolhouse and members' homes, the church accepted a free town lot in 1885 and completed a frame building in 1886. A 1918 tornado leveled that structure, but the congregation rebuilt in brick by 1919, adorning it with Pre-Raphaelite-style stained glass, and continues to serve Aubrey today.
Why it matters
From a frontier log cabin through a devastating cyclone, the church embodies the resilience of the pioneer congregations that helped settle North Texas.
The story behind this marker
AI contextThe era
When Dr. George T. Key brought his family from Missouri to Denton County in 1858, Texas had been a state for barely more than a decade and much of it was still frontier. Settlers arriving in this North Texas prairie built first in logs, and they built for necessity — a cabin might have to serve as home, schoolhouse, and church all at once. That is exactly what happened at the Key place near present-day Aubrey.
This was the world of the early Republic era's legacy carried into statehood: scattered families, few institutions, and a deep hunger for the two things that made a wilderness feel civilized — education for the children and a place to worship. On the frontier those two hungers were often met in the same rough-hewn room.
Out of such humble beginnings whole communities grew. The Key School House stood at the crossroads of that growth, and the Methodist congregation it sheltered would become one of the first in the county — an institution destined to outlast the cabin, the frontier, and even a catastrophe still decades away.
People & events
The through-line of this church's history is stubborn resilience, and it runs through a handful of memorable people. Dr. Key's log cabin, known as the Key School House, cradled one of Denton County's first Methodist congregations, which met there and in members' homes under the guidance of the Reverend F.V. Evans. It was faith conducted in borrowed and shared spaces, held together by conviction rather than comfort.
Growth came through generosity. In 1885, when L.N. Edwards laid out an addition to the town plat of Aubrey, he offered a free lot to each church, and the Methodists claimed the corner of Plum and Maple Streets. With church funds desperately scarce, a pioneer citizen named Ed F. Bates donated the money to raise a wood-frame building, completed in 1886.
Then came the disaster that tests the marker's whole theme. On April 14, 1918, a devastating tornado tore through Aubrey and destroyed the church outright. The congregation refused to fold; by February 1919 they had completed a new one-story brick-veneer building, filling its sanctuary with Pre-Raphaelite-style stained-glass windows depicting the stories of the faith. A 1968 denominational merger gave the church its present name, and a fellowship hall followed in 1986.
Its place in the American story
The arc from log cabin to brick church is the arc of frontier America itself — the way rough settlements matured into permanent towns, and the way religion and schooling led that maturation hand in hand. A single cabin serving as both school and church is one of the most quintessential images of how the American frontier was actually settled.
The congregation's rebuilding after the 1918 tornado connects it to the long American experience of communities absorbing natural disaster and refusing to be erased. Rebuilding in brick within a year, and doing it beautifully, was both a practical choice and a statement of permanence — a frontier church declaring it meant to stay.
Even the church's 1968 renaming reflects a national event: the merger that united the Methodist Church with the Evangelical United Brethren to form the United Methodist Church, reshaping one of America's largest Protestant families. A small Denton County congregation thus carries within its name a chapter of the nation's religious history.
If you visit
The reason to come is the light. Step into the 1919 sanctuary and look for the richly colored stained-glass windows the marker celebrates — their vivid scenes of the Christian faith are the congregation's answer to the storm that leveled what came before. Craftsmanship like that, in a small-town church, is a quiet marvel worth lingering over.
As you stand there, hold the whole timeline in mind: a log cabin in 1858, a donated lot in 1885, a frame church, a tornado, and this brick building rising within a year. Few small churches wear their resilience so plainly, and knowing the story turns an ordinary corner in Aubrey into something moving.
Aubrey sits in the countryside north of the Dallas–Fort Worth area, an easy addition to a day of exploring Denton County's small towns. Respect that this is an active congregation, admire the windows and the marker from an appropriate vantage, and let the place remind you how much history a modest church on a town corner can hold.
Written by AI to add context, grounded in the marker’s inscription and the historical record. The inscription above is the original, unaltered text.
Own a business near here? Add it to the map.
Related people
- · George T. Key
Themes & tags
Nearby & related markers
First Christian Church of Aubrey
Aubrey, TX
The Disciples of Christ in this area first worshipped alongside other denominations under a brush arbor and in a schoolhouse in the Spring Hill community before establishing their own Christian church in Aubrey in October 1894. A frame sanctuary served the congregation until a tornado leveled it in 1918, after which members quickly rebuilt while sustaining their missions and charitable work. An early emphasis on Bible schools fueled rapid growth and set the congregation's long course of worship and outreach.
The City of Denton
Denton, TX
Denton grew out of the Peters Colony land grant, with pioneers arriving in the 1840s and the county organized in 1846. Voters settled on this donated tract as the county seat in 1856, and within a year lots were auctioned, a post office opened, and a church took root. The city took its name from John B. Denton, a frontier minister killed in 1841, and later became a college town with the founding of Texas Normal College in 1890 and the College of Industrial Arts in 1903.
First Baptist Church of Denton
Denton, TX
Twelve men and women gathered in Denton County's log-cabin courthouse in 1858 to organize what they called the Union Baptist Church, meeting for years in borrowed Masonic and Presbyterian halls. Renamed First Baptist Church of Denton by about 1880, the congregation raised a succession of buildings—a white frame structure, a larger hall lost to fire in 1917, and a columned brick church in 1918—as its membership grew with the town. Across generations it became woven into Denton's civic and religious life.
Chinn's Chapel Methodist Church
Copper Canyon, TX
In 1846, pioneer settlers of the Peters Colony gathered in a log church-and-school building on land the Chinn family donated for a chapel and cemetery. Admitted to the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, in 1872, the congregation soon moved to freshwater springs that had drawn early camp meetings, raising a sanctuary and a tabernacle for summer revivals. For generations it doubled as lodge hall, school, and social hub before declining after World War II — only to be revived and renovated in the 1990s.